Despite the countless ads and commercials glamorizing perfect pearly white teeth, it’s important to remember that teeth naturally darken with age. Dentin, the hard, inner part of teeth, is primarily responsible for their color. As you get older, your enamel, the thin outer covering of teeth, may also affect your teeth’s appearance. While genetics cause teeth to vary in color from person to person, and even from tooth to tooth, other big factors are age and diet.